Criminal Allegations in a Divorce or Custody Case
An allegation made during a divorce or custody dispute is not just a family court problem. Once it becomes a police report, it is a criminal case. A criminal case has consequences that no family court order can undo.
Divorce and custody cases are some of the most emotional matters a person can face. They are also some of the most strategically manipulated. False and exaggerated allegations of domestic violence, child abuse or sexual misconduct spike when couples separate. A single police report can tip a custody case, force a parent out of the family home, and shape the judge’s view before any evidence has been tested.
When that happens, the family case and the criminal allegation both need careful attention. The attorneys handling them need to work together.
Divorce and Custody, in Brief
Hawaiʻi is a no-fault divorce state. Property is divided equitably, which does not automatically mean split in half. Custody is decided by a Family Court judge, without a jury, under a single standard: the best interests of the child.
Under that standard, the court must consider any history of family violence and any history of abuse of a child. If the court finds that a parent has committed family violence, Hawaiʻi law creates a strong presumption against giving that parent custody. That is why an allegation, and especially a conviction, can matter more in a custody case than anything else.
Questions We Are Asked Most
Both. And the criminal side can’t be negotiated away between spouses. Once police are involved, the prosecutor decides whether to charge, not the person who made the report. A report can turn into an arrest, then a charge, and then an exhibit in the custody hearing.
The criminal case runs on its own schedule in its own courtroom. It does not end because the divorce settles or the accuser changes their mind.
Because the stakes are different. A family law case decides custody, support and property. A criminal case can mean jail and a permanent conviction record. It can also mean a ban on owning or possessing firearms under state and federal law, and a record that shows up on job and housing background checks. Those consequences last long after the divorce.
Your family law attorney is rightly focused on the family case. The criminal allegation needs a lawyer focused on it, who knows how the State builds this kind of case and how to take it apart. And the two lawyers need to talk to each other. The most costly mistake in these cases is hiring both and letting them work separately. A position taken in one case can create an inconsistency that gets used against you in the other.
Yes. Sworn declarations, hearing testimony and deposition answers are all statements a prosecutor can get. What you tell a custody evaluator can end up in a written report. An explanation you give in family court to clear your name can become the State’s evidence.
That does not mean saying nothing in the family case. It means deciding what to say, when to say it, and whether to testify at all, with the criminal risk in mind. Your defense attorney and your family law attorney should make that decision together.
Right away, and possibly for good. When a defendant is charged with a domestic violence offense, the court can order no contact. That can restrict contact with the children and require the defendant to leave the family home. Months later, the custody judge sees that arrangement when deciding what is stable for the child.
The outcome of the criminal case matters even more. A conviction can supply the family-violence finding that triggers the presumption against custody. That is why the criminal case can’t be treated as a side issue.
Not until you understand what the plea will do in family court. A deal that looks lenient in criminal court, like no jail and a short probation, can still mean a conviction for a family-violence offense. That brings the firearms ban with it, and a finding the custody judge will read.
Sometimes a negotiated deal is the right answer. But that call should be made with both cases in mind, by your defense attorney and your family law attorney together. It should not be made under pressure to make one problem go away so you can deal with the other.
Don’t assume it will. Many police departments are trained to start by believing the person making the report. That means the investigation may look for evidence that supports the accusation instead of evidence that tests it.
To answer a false allegation, we gather the facts. We build a dated timeline and compare it with the filings in the divorce or custody case. We collect complete message threads, not just excerpts. We find records showing where each person actually was, earlier statements that said something different, and witnesses who were there. The sooner this work starts, the more evidence can be preserved.
Not without an attorney. Wanting to explain is natural, but it leads to a lot of damaging statements. What you say to an officer can be used in the criminal case and read back to you in the custody case.
Take it seriously. Even an unsubstantiated report can start an investigation that lasts months. It can create records that follow the accused, and it can be offered in family court as evidence of “concerning behavior.” It doesn’t take much to make a report, and a report can also lead to a criminal referral.
Anything you say to an investigator is a statement like any other. Talk to your defense attorney before you talk to them.
We handle divorce and custody matters on a limited basis, and when a case involves both criminal charges and a family court dispute, our focus is usually on defending the criminal matter and any related protective-order hearing. In those cases we work closely with your family law attorney, so the two proceedings stay coordinated and nothing said or filed in one case damages your position in the other.
If you do not yet have a family law attorney, contact us to talk about your situation. Depending on the case, we may handle the family court matter ourselves or refer you to counsel we work with regularly.
Brandon Segal spent almost a decade as a Deputy Prosecuting Attorney for the County of Maui, where he handled Family Court offenses and screened cases for charging. He knows how an allegation made at separation gets turned into a police report, how a prosecutor evaluates it, and where these cases tend to be weak.
An allegation used as leverage only works if no one tests it. Segal Law prepares every criminal case for trial, and the other side always knows who tries cases. That changes how much weight the allegation carries, in the criminal case and in the family case.
Contact Segal Law
False allegations can snowball quickly. The sooner the criminal side is defended, the sooner the story can be challenged and the evidence preserved. Call 808-865-2100 or use our confidential online form to schedule a consultation.
This page is general information about criminal allegations arising in a Hawaiʻi divorce or custody dispute and is not legal advice about your situation. Call 808-865-2100 or contact us online.
Talk to a lawyer who has worked as both a prosecutor and a defense attorney.
Segal Law offers a free consultation. Tell us what happened. Every conversation is confidential.